In a somewhat surprising turn of events, Netflix canceledDead Boy Detectives, prompting many viewers to wonder why the acclaimed show ended up on the streamer’s chopping block. A supernatural mystery series that’s infused with dark comedy,Dead Boy Detectivesconnects toThe Sandmanuniverse, which makes the show’s sudden cancelation even more perplexing. George Rexstrew and Jayden Revri play the series' titular ghostly sleuths, Edwin Payne and Charles Rowland, as they and the rest ofDead Boy Detectives' cast of charactersinvestigate Earth’s supernatural crimes. Unfortunately,the show’s inventive spin on the detective genre wasn’t enough to convince Netflix.
Praised by long-time fans for its faithfulness to Neil Gaiman and Matt Wagner’s DC Comics source material,Dead Boy Detectiveswas a hit with critics too, landing an impressive 92% on Rotten Tomatoes. Even thoughDead Boy Detectivesseason 1’s endingset up an intriguing second season that could have continued the show’s early success, Netflix didn’t quite see that potential. Viewers can still turn toThe Sandmanseason 2if they’re interested in spending more time in Gaiman and Wagner’s fascinating world, but, for now,Dead Boy Detectiveshas firmly landed in the afterlife.
In aVarietyexclusive,Netflix’s decision to cancelDead Boy Detectivesafter just one season becomes a little more understandable, as the show’s viewership numbers dropped pretty quickly — and steeply — following the eight-episode season’s premiere on June 10, 2025. Despite a solid opening,Dead Boy Detectives' first and only seasonclung to the Netflix Top 10 English TV charts for just three weeks after its release, peaking at number two on the lineup. While that run isn’t as impressive as some of Netflix’s mega-hits, it wasn’t a terrible turn — but other metrics weren’t so hot.
Dead Boy Detectives had an incredibly sharp decline, falling to a slim 1.8 million views by week three.
The Sandmanspin-offgarnered just 3.1 million views in its first three days on the platform. Although its views rose to just shy of 5 million during its first week,Dead Boy Detectiveshad an incredibly sharp decline, falling to a slim 1.8 million views by week three. After that, it vanished from the streamer’s Top 10 chart altogether. Netflix’s metrics for determining a show’s success or failure are often criticized for being obtuse. However,the streaming giant often cites a week-to-week drop-off as a major factor in its renewal decisions.
Dead Boy Detectives 12 Easter Eggs & DC Comics References Explained
The Netflix mystery series Dead Boy Detectives includes multiple Easter Eggs and DC Comics references, such as the cameos by Despair and Death.
The Sandman Spin-Off Follows In The Footsteps Of Shows Like 1899
Despite being one of thebest horror TV shows of 2024,Dead Boy Detectivesis continuing Netflix’s incredibly disappointing trend of axing well-received series after just one season. In 2022, a similar fate befell1899, a German sci-fi mystery series that felt like theperfectDarkreplacement. While1899made waves in its first few weeks and received high marks from critics and audiences alike, Netflix pulled the plug on the eight-episode, one-season show. Now,Dead Boy Detectivesjoins a Netflix graveyard that’s piled high with other genre series, from1899toThe OAandSense8.
10 Netflix Cancellations That Hurt Me The Most
It’s no secret that Netflix has a bad habit of nixing one or two-season shows with passionate fanbases, but these Netflix cancelations stung the most.
One of the biggest disappointments to come out ofDead Boy Detectives' sudden cancelation is the fact that the abrupt axing also impacts the largerSandmanuniverse. For starters, tons ofSandman characters appeared inDead Boy Detectives, which means certain stories play out across both shows. Plus,newSandmanseason 2 characters, like Orpheus, were first referenced inDead Boy Detectivesseason 1. Clearly,a lot of effort went into plotting the shows' crossover potential, so, suddenly, the cancelation ofDead Boy Detectiveshas also slashedThe Sandman’s epic scope.
Dead Boy Detectivesseason 1 is streaming on Netflix.
Dead Boy Detectives
Based on the DC series, Dead Boy Detectives is a supernatural comedy-mystery series created for Netflix. Two young men from different find one another in death but decide to skip the afterlife and remain among the living with a new purpose - to solve various supernatural mysteries the way only two deceased detectives can.
