Below Deck Down Underseason 3 may not be the most widely adored season of the series, but watching has me thinking a lot abouthow much better of a captain that Jason Chambers is thanBelow Deck Sailing Yacht’sGlenn Shephard. While Captain Jason and Captain Glenn have never really been pitted against one another professionally, both having experience in theBelow Deckfranchise encourages viewers to compare and contrast. After a difficultBelow Deck Sailing Yachtseason 5,many have been looking deeper into Captain Glenn and his leadership abilities, especially with Captain Jason’s high level of professionalism.
ThroughoutBelow Deck Sailing Yachtseason 5, viewers were met with a lot of resistance from Captain Glenn about the way Gary King, his longtime First Officer, was being treated and edited. After learning about the sexual misconduct allegations against Gary, Captain Glenn was expected to be a bit more dismissive of his former crew member, but his position on his longtime colleague was far more positive. Captain Jason, in contrast, has been working aboardBelow Deck Down Underseason 3’ssuperyacht and dealing with the crew’s behavior in a stern-but-fair manner.TheBelow Deckcaptains couldn’t be more different.

Jason Is More Firm With His Crew
He Knows Where The Line Is
Although Captain Jason and Captain Glenn are both good at their jobs in their own right,their behavior is often quite different on their iterations ofBelow Deck.While bothBelow Deck Down UnderandBelow Deck Sailing Yachttend to be the more relaxed versions of the series whileBelow DeckandBelow Deck Medcan be more serious,the Captains maintain very different crews. Captain Jason, who’s been part ofBelow Deck Down Undersince the beginning of the series, has always been seen as the most charming captain in the franchise, but he counters that with professionalism.
20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now
Reality TV is more popular than ever. With so many to choose from, here are some of the best reality TV shows to stream or watch right now.
Captain Jason knows how to be firm with his crew, especially when they’re stepping out of line. ThroughoutBelow Deck Down Under’srun, he’s been able to make quick calls on behavior that have quite literally saved the crew at times. DuringBelow Deck Down Underseason 2’s charter seasonwhen Luke Jones was caught attempting to sexually assault Margot Sisson, Captain Jason took quick action, terminating Luke and those who were supporting his behavior. While Captain Glenn has seen Gary’s poor behavior with women throughout their time onSailing Yacht,he’s never been firm about acting or correcting it.

Glenn Is More Forgiving Than Jason Is
He Tries To Appeal To The Crew’s Emotions
As Captain Glenn has moved through his time as Parsifal III’s captain both on and offBelow Deck Sailing Yacht,he’s been shown to be a forgiving person. While it’s not a bad characteristic,Captain Glenn’s penchant for forgiveness has cost him a lot of respect in recent seasons, especially when it comes to Gary and his behavior. Even prior to his sexual misconduct scandal, which has turned into a massive lawsuit for Gary and the production company behindBelow Deck,Gary was behaving unprofessionally with womenof all varieties on the show. Gary’s behavior rubbed viewers the wrong way.
AlthoughCaptain Glenn has been a fixtureonBelow Deck Sailing Yacht,his behavior has made it clear that he’s more interested in maintaining his relationships with his crew than doing the right thing. Seeing how quickly Captain Jason moved to right a wrong onBelow Deck Down Underseason 2 and knowing that Captain Glenn has been highly aware of the inappropriate behavior Gary’s perpetuated throughout his time onBelow Deck Sailing Yachthas really made me think. While I respect Captain Glenn,I don’t like that he’s so forgiving to someone like Gary, who doesn’t really deserve it.

Jason Would’ve Fired Gary If He Were In Glenn’s Shoes
He Wouldn’t Stand For Gary’s Behavior
ThroughoutBelow Deck Sailing Yachtseason 5, despite the fact thatGary took on a reduced roleat the behest of the editors behind the scenes of the show after his scandal came to light, it was clear that there was very little that had changed for the First Officer aboard Parsifal III.Captain Glenn and Gary’s relationship hasn’t become any different when it should’ve, and Gary’s job was secure throughout the season despite him doing things that should’ve gotten him fired. Outside of his misconduct scandal, Gary’s drinking became a serious issue aboard the sailing yacht, impacting the crew.
WhileCaptain Glenn stayed fairly quiet about it, Gary’s behavior was a major issue for the rest of the crew in a way that ultimately made it clear he should’ve been fired. Leaving the misconduct scandal out of it entirely, Gary’s drinking and the behavior that came with that should’ve left Captain Glenn without another choice, as he was behaving unprofessionally toward his subordinates. Captain Jason would’ve fired Gary swiftly if he’d been onBelow Deck Down Under,as he wouldn’t have been able to defend Gary’s behavior at all. Instead,Captain Glenn let things slide as he usually does.

Glenn Gets More Personal With Crew Members Than Jason
Captain Jason Maintains Professionalism
AlthoughGlennand Jason both have good relationships with their crew members, it’s clear that their relationships have become a detriment in Glenn’s circumstance while they’ve been beneficial for Jason. Captain Glenn often becomes too involved in his crew members when he’s working aboard Parsifal III, especially one’s he’s been invested in for years.Glenn’s relationship with Gary has been a problem, and if Colin MacRae hadn’t left beforeBelow Deck Sailing Yachtseason 5, it likely would’ve been a conflict of interest as well. Glenn has never refuted the lack of professionalism in his relationships with his crew members.
WhileCaptain Jason has always had good relationshipswith his crew, as well, it’s been notable that he understands his boundaries with those he works with. For example, Captain Jason’s relationship with his formerBelow Deck Down UnderChief Stew Aesha Scott was a great one. Jason and Aesha shared a great rapport with one another, but when it was speculated that Captain Jason and Aesha could be moving into unprofessional territory, theBelow Deck Down Undercaptain made it clear that Aesha was his colleague, but their relationship had boundaries.His professionalism makes him the betterBelow Deckcaptain.

Below Deck Down Underairs Mondays at 8 p.m. EST on Bravo.
Below Deck Down Under
Cast
Below Deck Down Under is a reality television series that follows the crew of a luxury yacht navigating the waters of Australia. Set against the backdrop of the Whitsunday Islands and the Great Barrier Reef, the show highlights the challenges and dramas of managing high-end, on-the-water hospitality while balancing personal dynamics among the crew members.
Below Deck Sailing Yacht
Below Deck Sailing Yacht is a spin-off of the Below Deck reality television series. Premiering on Bravo, the show follows the life of a Yacht crew as they attempt to navigate a busy Charter season in which many customers make use of a 177-foot sailing yacht. Over the first three seasons, the yacht has been to Greece, Croatia, and Spain.