InAmerican Horror Story, the most mistreated character of the whole series was Misty Day (Lily Rabe). Misty was one of the sweetest characters on the show, caring about every living creature, but she was still stern enough to ensure people wouldn’t walk all over her. Despite her loving and caring nature, Misty, known as The Swamp Witch, was burnt alive, trapped in a cemetery, ridiculed and trapped to spend eternity in her personal hell. Her ending inAmerican Horror Story: Covenreally upset audiences asAmerican Horror Story’sMisty Day didn’t deserve to sufferfor all eternity.
Four and a half years after the conclusion ofCoven,adisturbing new season subtitledApocalypseaired.In a sense,Apocalypse came across as"part two"ofCoven.The season featured allthe witches fromCoven(apart from Fiona Goode) and the events that happened in their lives between the end ofCovenand the start ofApocalypse.The return of all the witches meant thatMisty Day returned to the screen, continuing her story, allowing the character to escape from her personal hell and have a second chance at life, giving audiences what they had wanted for the last four years.

Misty Day Was The Most Mistreated Character In American Horror Story
The Character Was Isolated Most The Way ThroughCoven
Her first scene sawMisty Day being burnt at the stake for using witchcraft to bring a bird back to life.The murder was used as a warning for the other witches to hide their powers as they wouldn’t want to end up like Misty. When the character was resurrected, she was shown living alone and by herself in an isolated cabin. She was lonely and didn’t belong to a coven, so when Zoe needed somewhere to keep Kyle safe, Misty offered her place, not because she wanted to care for him, but because she didn’t want to be alone.
Madison felt threatened by Misty, so she used her magic to lock Misty in a coffin in a graveyard in an attempt to kill her.

When the character was accepted into the coven, she was believed to be the next supreme. Madison felt threatened by Misty, so she used her magic to lock Misty in a coffin in a graveyard in an attempt to kill her. Once Misty escaped, the coven turned on Madison, but they allowed both witches to take part in the seven wonders. Unfortunately, during the test of the seven wonders,Misty gets trapped in the death realm.This trapped her in her own personal hell, dissecting an endless number of frogs in a biology class while crying from heartbreak.
Misty’s Coven Ending Was Very Upsetting
The Character Didn’t Deserve Her Fate
Although Misty knew the dangers of competing in the seven wonders, she still didn’t deserve to spend all of eternity in her own Hell. Misty Day cared for every living creature, so having to kill an endless number of frogs was the most intense suffering she could possibly face. As well as this, the character was ridiculed every time she brought the frog back with her magic, showing thatevery time she was ridiculed in the show when she was alive it really got to herand affected her so much that it implemented itself into her own personal Hell.
This shows that Misty was unhappy whenever anyone would ridicule or make fun of her, such as referring to her as a Swamp Witch, showing the character to be mistreated on a higher level than what can be seen on the surface.This ending for Misty Day devastated audiences for years following the season finalewhere Misty lost her life. Luckily for audiences, season 8 of the show, subtitledApocalypse,allowed the character to be revisited and the ending to be revised into one more fitting for the character and to fulfill the wishes of the audience.

AHS: Apocalypse Gave Misty A Second Chance
Even When The Season Finale Undid The Events Of The Season, It Allowed Misty To Remain Happy
InApocalypse’sfifth episode, “Boy Wonder,“Misty is resurrected, allowing her to have a second chance at life.As well as this, she was reunited with her idol, Stevie Nicks, who ended up taking Misty away to rest and recharge for the rest of the season. Audiences had waited four and a half years for this moment, and at long last they received justice for Misty Day. Although she wasn’t a main character inApocalypseand only appeared in a handful of scenes, it was clearly important for the creatives behind the scenes to give her a happy ending.
It’s Been 6 Years And American Horror Story Still Hasn’t Recovered From This Season Ending Mistake
American Horror Story’s eighth season had a strong, solid story, but the ending ruined the whole season for lots of reasons and still hasn’t recovered
At theend ofAmerican Horror Story: Apocalypse, Mallory goes back in time and prevents all the events of the season from occurring, meaning that the whole season, including Misty’s happy ending, never happened. However, in the new timeline, Nan returns from the afterlife and offers Misty as a reward for Mallory’s heroics in saving the world. This means that it only took four years, but even with the timeline being wiped,American Horror Storyallowed Misty to have her happy ending and a second chance at life, just as she deserved after everything she had been put through.
American Horror Story
Cast
American Horror Story is a Horror Anthology series created by Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk. The franchise has seen stars like Connie Britton, Jessica Lange, Denis O’Hare, Zachary Quinto, Evan Peters, and Dylan McDermott. Each season follows a new premise and spans an array of horror genres like witches, ghosts, serial killers, and more.