For almost 3 decades, theDigimonandPokémonfranchises have been at war for the title of the original monster-taming series. While both ideas were born at similar times,Digimoncommenced as a spin-off of the iconic Tamagotchi andPokémonas one of the biggest names in the gaming industry.
When their respective anime shows were released, the battle became even more heated, with Ash’s fans claiming that Tai’s story was a copy of theirs. Years later, thanks to the outstandingly different paths both franchises have taken, it has become clear thatDigimonwas never meant to bePokemon’s copy, as its core ideas cannot be more different.
Digimon’s Anime Better Proves Their Differences
The Stories and Themes Are Nothing Alike
While theDigimonandPokémonfranchises have been rivals from the beginning, their battle for dominance most fans are aware of revolves around the television series. In 1997, Ash Ketchum was introduced to the world as the protagonist of the animated adaptation of the games, wherehe would remain for 25 more seasons. His story was simple: he traveled around the world, met fellow trainers, caught new Pokémon, and trained them to become stronger. While he usually developed deep bonds with his teams, they were more akin to pets than friends.
Two years later, theDigimon Adventureanime was released, marking the beginning of a decades-long journey thathas recently come to an end after 25 years. This show focused on the adventures of a group of kids in another dimension known as the Digital World. While there, they meet sentient creatures who reveal themselves as Digimon, monsters that inhabit the world in all shapes and sizes. So began a quest to find a way for the kids to return home while also battling the evil forces trying to destroy both the Digital and human worlds.
Digimon Perfected Isekai 25 Years Ago, And No Anime Has Quite Matched It Since
Why Digimon Adventures - the 1999 anime series classic still outshines modern isekai in storytelling, character depth, and emotional impact.
TheDigimonanime was a tale of friendship between the kids and their unique partners, with neither of the protagonists ever acquiring another creature. The fact that the monsters were able to speak and demonstrate emotions meant that the series could tackle heavier subjects, sometimes becomingfairly messed up and unsettling. While the heroes also used their Digimon for battle, this was more of a necessary evil rather than their entire motivation. When examined closely, there is almost no similarity between the plot and themes ofAdventureand those ofPokémon Indigo League.
Digimon’s Origins Further Prove Its Originality
The Series Is Based on Building Friendships
In 1997, Bandai shocked the world by releasing a new model of their most popular toy at the time, theTamagotchi. This version would be focused on a young male audience, as the previous virtual pets were designed around girls. The project was calledDigimon, and it soon became a massive success. The year before, Game Freak had changed gaming history forever with the release of the originalPokémon Red and Greentitles,some of the best games ever released.
The short time between the releases caused many to accuseDigimonof copying Nintendo’s success, although the virtual pet had been in development long beforePokémonwas released. The concept of Bandai’s toy was nowhere near that of its competitor, and this could be seen in the core gameplay mechanics.Digimonwas a toy about taking care of a simple creature, helping it grow and evolve into its most powerful form. The player’s actions or lack thereof directly affect their friend, with bad caretakers receiving weak and often gross monsters.
After Being Stripped From Streaming, Digimon Just Got a Lot Easier to Watch
Hulu’s revolving door of Digimon proves once again that streaming remains the least reliable way to consume media.
Pokémonis a game about capturing several creatures and using them to defeat other trainers. Its simple yet rewarding gameplay prioritized strategy over anything else, and the creatures used by the players required little to no care. Although their premises can be slightly similar on the surface, their mechanics and end goals are completely different. If not for their similar releases, both franchises could have been appreciated for their unique strengths and weaknesses.
Digimon’s Other Entries Diverged Even More
The Series Did Not Maintain the Same Formula
Despite the premise ofDigimon Adventurenot being nearly as similar toPokemon’s as many fans would expect, what cements their differences are the following entries in the series. While Ash’s journey to becomeone of the strongest trainers in his franchisewas continuous for more than 20 years, Bandai took a different approach to its continuity. After the release ofDigimon Adventure 02, the only official direct sequel that is not a movie, the series decided to explore different universes with completely new casts of characters.
From the widely beloved Tamers tothe recently announcedBeatbreak anime, each show followed a plot unrelated to the previous. The formula of theDigimonfranchise changes constantly, as the team behind the series often attempts to maintain a sense of novelty and excitement. While not all entries have been as successful, the franchise has never attempted to release a direct anime sequel again. Not even the most ardentDigimoncritics can argue that this formula is in any way similar to the one used by the Pokémon franchise.
Pokémon and Digimon Deserve Praise and Admiration
Both Franchises Have Been Pillars of the Anime Industry for Decades
Even though a bit of competitive spirit between two of the most successful monster-taming franchises can be fun and healthy, there is no need for anime fans to attack either one.PokémonandDigimonare both largely responsible for some of the biggest trends in the anime industry, and their repercussions continue to be felt even to this day. For some fans, Ash’s quest to become a true master might be better, while for others, the heroes of the Digital World and their partners could be more appealing.
At the end of the day,PokémonandDigimonare incredible series that will forever be held dear in the hearts of millions of fans all over the world. Followers of these amazing franchises should engage each other with the respect and admiration that these giants of animation have earned.
Digimon
TheDigimonfranchise, created in 1997, encompasses digital pets, anime, manga, films, video games, and a trading card game, all centering on creatures called Digimon who inhabit a parallel “Digital World.” The series typically follows young humans and their Digimon partners battling threats and evolving through various forms.
Pokémon
Cast
Pokémon follows Ash Ketchum on his journey to become a Pokémon Master, accompanied by his loyal Pikachu. Released in 1997, the series explores Ash’s travels through various regions, where he encounters new friends and challenges, underscoring the themes of adventure and teamwork.
